​OCD: Myth vs Reality

Hayley McCraw, LCMHCA

Psychotherapist

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) has a large presence in pop culture from the frequently used phrase “I’m so OCD,” to depictions on shows or movies, to presence in Mental Health TikTok and other social media. Like anything in pop culture, it can be hard to tell what is accurate and based in reality over incomplete or sensationalized depictions.

Misconception: All people with OCD are really clean and organized.

Reality: While some people with OCD may appear to be incredibly clean or organized, this is only one way OCD can show up.

Part of the reason some people with OCD may appear clean and organized is due to intrusive thoughts, or obsessions related to fear of contamination or intense, persistent discomfort if something is not arranged “just right.” This leads to feeling the strong urge to perform a behavior (a compulsion) to reduce the anxiety. That might look like regimented cleaning, meticulous organizing, or other repetitive behaviors.

OCD is much broader than just that. Some common themes include fears of harming oneself or others, fear of something bad happening, morally “forbidden” thoughts, contamination, hoarding, and symmetry/order.

Misconception: Compulsions are always obvious actions such as flipping a light switch on and off or excessive hand washing.

Reality: While there is truth to this and some compulsions may be visible, others may be unseen mental rituals.

Mental compulsions might include replaying conversations over and over to make sure nothing “wrong” was said, or repeating phrases internally to reassure yourself that nothing bad will happen. Reassurance isn’t inherently harmful, but it becomes problematic when a person feels dependent on it and distressed if they can’t repeat it.

Some other examples of compulsions include rewriting messages multiple times until they feel “perfect,” repeatedly checking stoves or locks, regimentedly monitoring your temperature to make sure you aren’t sick, or frequently asking others for reassurance.

Misconception: If a person with OCD has intrusive thoughts of harming others, they must be dangerous.

Reality: Intrusive thoughts are the opposite of intent. They are unwanted, distressing, and directly oppose what the individual genuinely wants to do.

By definition, intrusive thoughts are thoughts a person does not want to have. They often target a person’s core values or greatest fears. For example, someone who values peaceful interactions may experience intrusive images or thoughts of harming others. The distress comes from how upsetting the thought is, not from any desire to act on it.

Experiencing intrusive thoughts does not mean a person is dangerous. However, if someone has actual intent or plans to harm themselves or others, it is important to seek professional support and contact emergency services in the case of a true crisis.

Misconception: All therapists are trained to effectively treat OCD.

Reality: Unfortunately, many therapists are not due to the specialized nature of working with OCD.

Before I (as a therapist and the author of this post) pursued additional post-graduate training, I didn’t have the tools to effectively support clients with OCD. In fact, some common therapy strategies such as challenging irrational thoughts and replacing them with more realistic ones or offering reassurance can unintentionally reinforce OCD symptoms.

The gold standard treatment for OCD is Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP). ERP involves slowly and safely facing anxiety-provoking situations while learning to manage the urge to carry out compulsions. Over time, this helps reduce the power of obsessions and break the cycle that keeps OCD going: Trigger → Distress → Compulsion → Temporary Relief → Repeat.

Misconception: Medication won’t help OCD, or medication is the only answer.

Reality: Medication can be supportive for the treatment for OCD but is not appropriate for everyone and the decision should be made on an informed, case-by-case basis.

Medication can be very helpful in reducing OCD symptoms and supporting overall treatment. However, some medications may interfere with certain therapeutic strategies, and medication alone does not address the underlying OCD cycle. Combining medication with evidence-based therapy can provide the most effective long-term results.

The best approach is individualized, involving collaboration between the client, therapist, and a prescribing provider to determine whether medication, therapy, or a combination is most supportive.

Misconception: Having OCD means there is something wrong with me or that it’s my fault.

Reality: OCD is not a character flaw or a personal failing.

OCD is a condition influenced by a combination of genetic, neurological, and environmental factors. Experiencing obsessions and compulsions does not mean you are broken or at fault. With appropriate support, OCD can be effectively managed and people can live meaningful, fulfilling lives.

OCD is a complex experience that goes far beyond common stereotypes or myths. Understanding the reality of obsession and compulsions helps reduce stigma and self blame. With accurate information, compassion, and evidence-based treatment, people with OCD can regain a sense of control and build a life aligned with their values.

Hayley McCraw, LCMHCA

Book with Hayley here!